Best Cold Email Software 2025: Instantly vs Smartlead vs Apollo

By Muhammad Wani | January 6, 2025 | 10 min read

I've sent over 5 million cold emails using virtually every cold email platform on the market. Instantly, Smartlead, Apollo, Lemlist, Woodpecker, Reply.io—you name it, I've probably tested it across dozens of campaigns.

And here's what nobody tells you: the tool matters way less than you think. I've gotten 16.7% reply rates on Instantly and 2.1% reply rates on Instantly. Same tool, different approach.

But that doesn't mean all tools are created equal. Some are better for specific use cases. Some have features that genuinely make a difference. And some will save you hours of time.

This is my honest comparison of the top cold email tools in 2025, based on actual usage across 100+ campaigns.

The Tools I'm Comparing

I'll focus on the four platforms I use most frequently:

I'm leaving out platforms like Woodpecker, Reply.io, and Mailshake not because they're bad, but because these four represent the best options for most users in 2025.

Quick Comparison Table

Feature Instantly Smartlead Apollo Lemlist
Starting Price $30/mo $39/mo $49/mo $59/mo
Email Accounts Unlimited Unlimited Limited Unlimited
Built-in Database Yes (150M+) No Yes (270M+) Yes (450M+)
Warmup Included Yes Yes No Yes
Best For Beginners Scale Sales teams Creative campaigns

Instantly.ai - Best for Beginners

What It Is

Instantly has become the default recommendation for cold email, and for good reason. It's the easiest platform to get started with, has the cleanest interface, and includes everything you need in one place.

Key Features

✅ Pros

  • Easiest to learn (15-minute setup)
  • Unlimited accounts at every tier
  • Excellent deliverability tracking
  • Great support and community
  • Constant updates and improvements
  • Best warmup system

❌ Cons

  • Database quality varies
  • Limited advanced automation
  • Can get expensive at scale
  • No A/B testing on lower tiers
  • Basic reporting compared to alternatives

Pricing

Who Should Use Instantly

Instantly is perfect if you're:

My Take: Instantly is my default recommendation for 80% of users. It just works, the interface is clean, and you won't get overwhelmed with features you don't need. If you're starting out, this is the safest choice.

Smartlead - Best for Scale

What It Is

Smartlead is Instantly's main competitor and is better in several ways—if you're willing to deal with a slightly more complex setup. It's built for people who need to send high volumes and want more control.

Key Features

✅ Pros

  • Better for high volume (cheaper per email)
  • More advanced automation features
  • Superior email rotation algorithms
  • White label option for agencies
  • More flexible API access
  • Better inbox management

❌ Cons

  • Steeper learning curve
  • No built-in lead database
  • Interface less intuitive
  • Support can be slow
  • More bugs and quirks

Pricing

Who Should Use Smartlead

Smartlead makes sense if you're:

My Take: Smartlead is technically superior to Instantly in many ways, but the learning curve is real. If you're experienced with cold email or need to scale to millions of emails, this is the better choice. But most beginners will struggle with it.

Apollo.io - Best All-in-One Platform

What It Is

Apollo is different from the others—it's a full sales engagement platform that happens to include cold email. Think of it as a CRM, lead database, and cold email tool combined.

Key Features

✅ Pros

  • Best lead database (quality and quantity)
  • All-in-one solution (CRM + email + calls)
  • Great for sales teams
  • Chrome extension is powerful
  • Intent data actually works
  • Excellent reporting

❌ Cons

  • No email warmup included
  • Limited sending accounts
  • More expensive than alternatives
  • Overkill if you only need email
  • Slower interface (lots of features)
  • Email deliverability tracking is basic

Pricing

Who Should Use Apollo

Apollo is ideal if you:

My Take: Apollo is incredible if you need more than just cold email. The database alone is worth it. But if you're only doing email outreach, you're paying for features you won't use. Also, you'll need separate email warmup (I use Instantly's warmup for Apollo campaigns).

Lemlist - Best for Creative Campaigns

What It Is

Lemlist pioneered creative personalization in cold email—dynamic images, videos, and landing pages. If you want to stand out visually, this is the tool.

Key Features

✅ Pros

  • Best creative personalization tools
  • LinkedIn automation included
  • Great for standing out visually
  • Strong deliverability features
  • Good customer support
  • Nice user interface

❌ Cons

  • Most expensive option
  • Creative features take time to set up
  • Overkill for simple campaigns
  • Steeper learning curve
  • Can be slow with large lists

Pricing

Who Should Use Lemlist

Lemlist makes sense if you:

My Take: Lemlist is powerful but requires more work. The image/video personalization is cool, but most prospects don't care as much as you think. I use it for high-value campaigns where I'm targeting 50-100 dream clients. For volume campaigns, it's overkill.

My Tool Stack (What I Actually Use)

Here's my honest setup across different scenarios:

For My Own Campaigns

I use Instantly for 90% of my work. It's fast, reliable, and I don't need to think about it.

For High-Volume Client Campaigns

I use Smartlead when sending 500,000+ emails per month. The cost per email is lower and the advanced features matter at that scale.

For Lead Generation

I use Apollo to build lists, then export and send via Instantly or Smartlead. Apollo's database is unmatched.

For High-Value ABM Campaigns

I use Lemlist when targeting 50-100 dream clients where personalization ROI justifies the effort.

Which Tool Should YOU Choose?

Decision Framework

Choose Instantly if: You're new to cold email, sending under 50K emails/month, or want the easiest platform.

Choose Smartlead if: You're experienced with cold email, sending 100K+ emails/month, or need advanced automation.

Choose Apollo if: You need a full sales platform, have a sales team, or want the best lead database.

Choose Lemlist if: You're doing ABM, targeting high-value prospects, or want creative personalization.

The Features That Actually Matter

After sending 5+ million emails, here's what I've learned actually impacts results:

Must-Have Features

Nice-to-Have Features

Overrated Features

Common Mistakes When Choosing a Tool

Mistake 1: Choosing Based on Features You Won't Use

Don't pay for advanced automation if you're running simple 3-email sequences. Most users never touch 80% of a platform's features.

Mistake 2: Ignoring Total Cost of Ownership

Apollo looks cheaper until you add email warmup ($30/month), email accounts ($20/month), and per-user pricing. Calculate your true monthly cost.

Mistake 3: Switching Tools Too Often

I see people switch tools every 2-3 months chasing better results. The tool isn't the problem—your targeting and copy are. Master one platform before switching.

Mistake 4: Not Testing the Free Trial

Every platform offers trials. Use them. Set up a real campaign and see how it feels. Interface matters more than you think.

My Honest Recommendation

If you're reading this and feeling overwhelmed, here's my simple advice:

Start with Instantly.

It's the best balance of features, ease of use, and price for 80% of users. Yes, Smartlead might be slightly better for volume. Yes, Apollo has a better database. Yes, Lemlist has cooler personalization.

But Instantly will get you results faster because you'll actually understand how to use it.

You can always switch later once you understand cold email better. I started with Woodpecker, moved to Lemlist, tried Reply.io, and now primarily use Instantly because it just works.

The best tool is the one you'll actually use consistently.

Final Thoughts

Here's what matters more than your tool choice:

I've gotten 16.7% reply rates with basic tools and 2% reply rates with advanced platforms. The tool doesn't make the difference—your strategy does.

Choose a tool, learn it well, and focus on improving your fundamentals. That's what actually moves the needle.

Need Help Choosing the Right Tool?

I've tested every major cold email platform and can recommend the best setup for your specific needs. Let's talk about your goals and budget.

Book a Free Consultation

About the Author: Muhammad Wani has sent over 5 million cold emails using virtually every platform on the market. He helps B2B companies and consultants build cold email systems that generate consistent pipeline.

Related Articles: